Article
Overcoming challenges with strategic chart of accounts redesign
Optimize your move to Cloud ERP
Mar 24, 2025 · Authored by Amanda Dzvairo
In the rush to adopt Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) cloud solutions, organizations often lack a clear strategy, presenting both challenges and opportunities for Chief Financial Officers (CFOs) and Controllers. As financial stewards, CFOs must lead the transformation of financial management by developing robust use cases that outline the benefits, costs, governance and return on investment (ROI) of ERP applications. Optimizing ERP implementations through a chart of accounts redesign and leveraging industry best practices can ensure optimal performance and strategic growth.
Legacy Chart of accounts (CoA) tends to have crippling limitations: too many subcategories, missing details or outdated accounts. Some organizations may have suboptimal CoA due to legacy decisions and poor governance, while many others are operating with multiple chart of accounts due to acquisitions. These issues make it hard to analyze transactions, create accurate reports and make informed business decisions. Emerging accounting standards and new compliance regimes cannot be met by CoA deployed decades ago. Net result is that the much-needed efficiencies continue to elude many organizations’ transactions, accounting and reporting processes.
CoA design guiding principles
Charting a new course
Charting a new course would require redesigning the CoA for cloud-based ERP following the guardrails discussed above. This creates efficiencies that most times were thought not possible. Budgeting, transactions, financials and management reporting, and consolidation needs necessitate a CoA redesign in order get full value of an ERP implementation.
In case of reimplementation and migration from legacy systems, mapping and transformation of existing legacy data is critical to achieving desired outcomes. CoA are composed of different dimensions across various industries, making CoA design unique across the industries. In addition, system defined elements will vary for each ERP deployment.
Measuring success
Quantitative metrics
- Accuracy and efficiency
- Compliance and reporting
- Cost savings
- Scalability
Qualitative metrics
- User satisfaction
- Strategic alignment
- Risk management
System and integration metrics
- ERP/software compatibility
Benchmarking
- Pre vs. post-redesign comparisons
- Industry standards
- Ensure compliance
Long term indicators
- Adaptability to change
- Sustainability
Key performance indicators (KPIs)
- Automation
- Support audit
- User experience
Baker Tilly & Oracle
Redesigning a chart of accounts (COA) is a strategic overhaul that aligns an organization’s financial infrastructure with its evolving needs and goals. Modernizing the COA enhances financial reporting clarity, streamlines regulatory compliance and empowers data-driven decision-making. It fosters scalability, improves efficiency, strengthens risk management, supports sustainability initiatives and enhances cross-departmental collaboration. Despite requiring careful planning and stakeholder alignment, the long-term benefits—such as cost savings and strategic agility—far outweigh the initial effort, positioning organizations to navigate complexity and thrive in a dynamic business landscape.
Ready to learn more?